Fire TV 4k

2017 Rokus vs 2017 Fire TV vs 2017 Apple TV – We Break Them Down

In 2017 three of the four streaming media player manufacturers released major updates to their streaming players. (Google has a press event scheduled for tomorrow. It is possible it will also launch a new streaming player.)

So I wanted to take an in-depth look at how the new streaming players line up side-by-side on many areas I get asked about the most.

4K HDR Support

The new Apple TV, Fire TV, Roku 4K Stick, and Roku Ultra all support 4K HDR. There are a few different standards of HDR. Roku and Amazon have gone with the HDR 10 standard and Apple is supporting both the HDR 10 and the HDR Dolby Vision standard.

Want to learn more about HDR 10 vs HDR Dolby Vision? Check out this story from TechRadar.

Speed Improvements

Both Roku and Apple’s players are noticeably faster. The new Roku Express, for example, is five times more powerful. All other Roku players now use a quad-core processor.

The Apple TV 4K used the new A10X Fusion processor, a big jump over the dual core processor of the Apple TV 4th gen. The A10X Fusion processor is a three-core processor with integrated graphics.

The 3rd gen Fire TV is a quad-core ARM Cortex-A53 CPU up to 1.5GHz. This looks to be slightly slower than the ARM Cortex 72 2GHz processor of the 2nd gen Fire TV. We wont know for sure until we get out hands on it later this month.

Voice Controls

All three manufacturers now offer voice controls—not just for voice searches but the ability to ask for channels to launch among other voice commands—with their new players. (Note the Roku Express is the only Roku player now without voice controls.)

Pricing

The Roku lineup starts at $29.99 for the Roku Express HD player and goes up to $99.99 for its high-end Roku Ultra.

The Fire TV 3rd gen costs $69.99.

The Apple TV 4K starts at $179.99.

Single Sign-On

Both of the new Roku players and the Apple TV 4K will support single sign-on, which allows you to login one time and access multiple streaming apps. No longer do you need to log into each app individually.

At this time Amazon’s 3rd gen Fire TV does not support single sign-on, but it is reported that Amazon’s working on it.

Remotes

All of the new streaming players, except for the low-end Roku Express, include a point-anywhere remote. (The Roku Stick and above include a point-anywhere remote.)

The new Roku Stick, 4K Roku Stick, and Roku Ultra all offer the ability to power on and off your TV and control the volume.

The Apple TV 4K will also allow you to control the volume on your TV.

Final Thoughts

Increasingly the speed and performance of the streaming players all look similar. At the time of this posting, the new Rokus and the new Fire TV are not on the market yet. On paper they look the same, but without getting them in our lab to put them head to head we see little difference in the specs.

Our suggestion at this point is to get the player you are already familiar with.

Want an in-depth look at each player? You can find our look at the new Roku players HERE, the 2017 Fire TV HERE, and the Apple TV 4K HERE.

Please follow us on Facebook and Twitter for more news, tips, and reviews.

Need cord cutting tech support? Join our new Cord Cutting Tech Support Facebook Group for help.

3 Responses to 2017 Rokus vs 2017 Fire TV vs 2017 Apple TV – We Break Them Down

  1. Aaron McBroom October 3, 2017 at 8:58 am #

    No mention of RAM & storage in a feature and price comparison article?

  2. MacHead84 October 3, 2017 at 9:46 am #

    I can turn on my TV with my Apple TV….and you can program it to work with ANY remote not just the Apple provided remote.

  3. 24fantothecore October 3, 2017 at 10:57 am #

    FYI: I was just at my local Walmart and they are already selling the new Roku Express, Express +, Streaming Stick, and the Streaming Stick + and it is not even October 8 yet. They do not have the new Ultra out on the shelf yet.